The Hidden Challenges of Building a World-Class CRE Brokerage Team

A top-performing commercial real estate broker can generate millions in annual revenue working solo. Yet even these star performers often stumble when building a team to scale their business. Why? Because the skills that make a great broker don't automatically translate to effective team leadership.

The Promise and Peril of Team Building

The math seems simple: combine multiple successful brokers, and you'll multiply your success. In practice, the dynamics are far more complex. While a well-structured team can dramatically increase market share and deal flow, poor execution can turn a promising collaboration into a costly liability.  The goal in building a team is to create synergy, where the sum (the revenue production of the team) is greater than the sum its parts (the individual success each team member might have if they weren’t on the team).

The Real Benefits of Successful Teams

When executed properly, CRE brokerage teams deliver powerful advantages:

• Enhanced Market Coverage: Teams can service more deal flow, both in quality and quantity.
• Increased Market Intelligence: Each team member's expertise and relationships benefit the whole, fast-tracking junior broker development and funneling market information up the most senior team leaders.  More touch points equates to a better collective pulse of the market.
• Improved Client Service: Larger teams can handle more complex transactions, increase their win rate of more valuable opportunities and provide prospects and clients with deeper market insights.
• Stronger Brand Presence: Multiple successful brokers operating under one banner amplify market recognition which increases prospect and client trust.
• Best Practice Sharing: The collective sharing of best practices accelerates the growth of everybody else, particularly the younger brokers who, the faster they grow in their expertise, the greater their value to the team.

The Seven Critical Challenges That Sink Most Teams

1. The Commission Conundrum

"In an industry where you eat what you kill, how do you foster cohesive collaboration at a high level?"

Most CRE brokers operate as 100% commission-paid, independent contractors, creating an inherent tension between individual and team success. If the team is generating a fortune in revenue but one broker is not, that broker will never be on the same page as their team members in celebrating the team’s victories.  As stated earlier, the goal for a team should be to create a synergistic effect where the whole (the team’s overall revenue production) is greater than the sum of its parts (each individual broker’s personal success without the team).  This fundamental challenge requires careful structuring of:

• Clear commission split protocols that are established and everybody is bought into, ideally well before deals even start
• Recognition of both business development ("hunters") and client servicing ("gatherers") roles
• Transparent tracking of contribution and value
• Routine review of and modifications to the Team’s incentive protocols

Success Strategy: Create a tiered commission structure that rewards both individual performance and team contribution. Document all agreements and review quarterly.  Ensure that every Team member is bought in.  Don’t be afraid to have blunt conversations around these matters.

2. The Knowledge Transfer Trap

"Your senior brokers' expertise is your greatest asset - but only if they can effectively leverage it for the greater good of the team."

Many teams fail to systematically transfer knowledge from senior to junior members. This is often the result of senior broker carelessness but it’s often just the result of being too busy to be attentive to the needs of more junior members.  Either way, the net result leads to:

• Team growth stagnation 
• Repeated and potentially devastating mistakes across deals
• Bottlenecks in decision-making
• Lost institutional knowledge when key members depart

Success Strategy: Implement structured knowledge sharing through weekly deal review sessions, discussions around best practices, establishment of core values, dedicated 1-on-1 meetings between senior and junior brokers and regular market analysis presentations by senior team members.

3. Technology Resistance

"Teams want to embrace technology but so much of the technology is not designed for how CRE brokerage teams really operate."

Despite massive advances in CRE technology, many teams struggle with:

• Information silos between team members
• Inconsistent adoption of new tools
• Resistance from senior brokers to change established practices

Success Strategy: Start with one core system and ensure:

• Senior leadership sets an example for consistent usage
• Clear protocols for data entry and sharing
• Measurable efficiency gains
• The core system is easy to use

4. The Role Ambiguity Crisis

"When everyone's responsible, no one's responsible."

As teams grow, unclear responsibilities lead to:

• Duplicated efforts
• Dropping the ball on critical tasks
• Lack of trust as more junior members don’t meet undefined expectations
• Internal frustration (largely due to incentive mismanagement)

Success Strategy: Create clear frameworks for client relationship ownership, deal execution responsibilities, prospecting responsibilities (with KPI’s) and clear communication protocols.

5. Poor Leadership (Senior Brokers)

"Great brokers don't automatically make great leaders."

Poor leadership manifests in multiple ways:

• Senior brokers bringing on junior brokers primarily for business development grunt work the senior brokers don’t want to do (this is a common experience across teams - senior brokers who don’t actually want to grow the pie or elevate more junior members but who instead want to use junior brokers for the sole purpose of scaling their personal business)
• Focusing solely on transactions while neglecting team development
• Hoarding relationships and information
• Lacking clear strategic direction

Success Strategy: Invest in leadership development through executive coaching for team leaders, regular strategic planning sessions, establishing a clear vision, values and performance metrics, particularly around prospecting and non-deal activities.

6. Poor Followership (Less Senior Brokers)

"Balancing patience with drive is an art form."

Teams struggle with junior brokers who either:

• Expect instant success without putting in the groundwork
• Lack the entrepreneurial drive needed for commission-based work
• Feel entitled for doing lots of less valuable work (often the result of ignorance as to what it really takes to execute the business as opposed to simply winning it)
• Jump ship before generating meaningful value for the team

Success Strategy: Improve junior broker success through realistic expectations set during the hiring process, clear development pathways for growth, regular feedback and coaching and ensuring that junior brokers receive early wins through deal participation.  The earlier a junior broker receives the feeling of closing a deal and making a little money, the more likely they will chase that incentive; far too many junior brokers never experience a meaningful win and lose their motivation.

7. The Process Problem

"Without systems, even star teams underperform."

Many teams lack standardized processes for:

• Deal tracking and reporting
• Client communication
• Market research
• Business development
• Team meetings and communication

Success Strategy: Build foundational processes that scale with team growth; maintain flexibility for different deal types; support rather than restrict broker autonomy; generate measurable efficiency gains.

Building Your Path to Success

Immediate Action Steps

1. Audit your current team structure and identify top pain points
2. Document a standardized commission structure and clearly establish role responsibilities
3. Implement one core technology solution for team collaboration
4. Create a structured knowledge sharing program
5. Establish clear metrics for team and individual success

Long-term Investment Areas

1. Leadership development for senior team members
2. Establish a systematic junior broker training model
3. Schedule regular strategic planning and team alignment sessions
4. Seek out the best possible technology infrastructure

Technology as the Team Multiplier

While technology alone won't solve team challenges, the right platform can:

• Streamline collaboration without sacrificing broker autonomy (Enaia’s Team feature and “Controlled Collaboration” architecture)
• Provide visibility into team performance and pipeline (Enaia’s Teams Analytics dashboard)
• Support different transaction types and workflows (Enaia’s various Representation Type workflows)
• Generate actionable insights for team leadership (Enaia’s Team Feature)

The key is choosing technology that adapts to how your team works, rather than forcing your team to adapt to the technology.

Conclusion: The Path Forward

Building a successful CRE brokerage team is one of the industry's greatest challenges - but also one of its greatest opportunities. By addressing these seven critical challenges head-on, teams can create sustainable competitive advantages and deliver superior results for their clients.

The future belongs to teams that can balance the entrepreneurial spirit of individual brokers with the power of true collaboration. It requires dedication, systems thinking, and a genuine commitment to developing people - but the rewards make it worth the investment.

Why CRE Brokers Run Their Team on Enaia?

Managing these complex Team dynamics requires technology that truly understands how CRE brokerage Teams operate. Enaia's Teams feature was developed specifically to address these challenges through a unique 'Controlled Collaboration' approach. Enaia’s Controlled Collaboration architecture enables CRE brokers to maintain their entrepreneurial independence while selectively sharing critical data with their Team – striking the essential balance between individual autonomy and Team coordination so that all Team members see what matters most without excessive data sharing that CRE brokers loathe.

The platform recognizes that different transaction types require different workflows, seamlessly supporting Occupier Representation, Landlord Representation, and Investment Sales all in one system. Team leaders can gain valuable insights through analytics that track KPI’s (Key Performance Indicators) across business development, prospecting and client meetings, and deal flow progression. This data-driven approach helps Teams identify strengths, address gaps, and make informed decisions about resource allocation and professional development.

Most importantly, the technology adapts to how Teams actually work, rather than forcing Teams to change their processes to fit the technology. Some of the world’s largest and most dynamic Teams run on Enaia to maximize their capabilities.  By focusing on practical tools that enhance rather than restrict broker autonomy, CRE brokerage Teams can improve collaboration and efficiency without sacrificing the entrepreneurial spirit that drives success in commercial real estate.

‍